Two routes to life with less reliance on glasses
If you are tired of glasses or contact lenses, you have probably come across two main options: laser eye surgery and implantable contact lenses, usually known as ICLs. Both can correct short sight, long sight and astigmatism, and both are carried out by experienced surgeons. They work in very different ways, though, and the right one for you depends on your eyes rather than on which sounds more appealing.
The ICL vs laser eye surgery question comes up at almost every consultation, so here is how the two compare and when an ICL is likely to be recommended. Every eye is different, and only a full assessment with a consultant can confirm what suits you.
How laser eye surgery works
Laser eye surgery corrects your vision by reshaping the cornea, the clear front surface of the eye. The laser removes a precise amount of tissue so that light focuses properly on the retina. There are several versions, including LASIK, which creates a thin flap in the cornea first, and surface treatments such as TransPRK and LASEK, which work without a flap.
For most people with a suitable prescription, laser is a well-established and effective choice. To be a good candidate, you generally need a stable prescription for at least 12 months, healthy eyes and adequate corneal thickness for safe reshaping. Our laser eye surgery options page explains each procedure in more detail.
How implantable contact lenses work
An ICL takes a different approach. Instead of reshaping the cornea, your surgeon places a thin, flexible lens inside the eye, behind the iris and in front of your natural lens. The lens works alongside your eye’s own focusing system, much like a contact lens, except that it stays in place permanently and you cannot feel it.
Because nothing is removed from the cornea, ICL surgery is described as additive rather than subtractive. It is also reversible, as the lens can be removed or exchanged if your prescription changes or a problem develops.
When implantable contact lenses are usually recommended
An ICL is most often recommended when laser is not a suitable choice. The main reasons include:
- A cornea that is too thin to be reshaped safely
- A higher prescription than laser can comfortably correct
- A cornea or eye surface that makes laser less suitable
Higher prescriptions are the most common reason. The Royal College of Ophthalmologists notes in its patient information on implantable lenses that laser is generally preferred for lower prescriptions, while these lenses can treat a wider range. It adds that patients under 60 who are unsuitable for laser are often offered an implant instead.
When laser is often the better choice
For many people, laser remains the first option. If your prescription is lower and your corneas are healthy and thick enough, laser can correct your vision without any surgery inside the eye, and without a lens that stays there for the long term.
A thin cornea does not automatically point to an ICL, either. Surface treatments such as LASEK and PRK are often suited to thin or irregular corneas, and to people who play contact sports. That is why your consultant will measure your corneas, check your prescription and look at the health of your eye surface before suggesting anything. The recommendation comes from your results, not from a preference for one procedure.
What if you are over 40?
Age changes the picture. Around your mid-forties, the eye’s natural focusing power begins to fade, and many people find they need reading glasses whatever they do about their distance vision. An ICL or standard laser treatment will not stop that from happening.
If your near vision is already declining, or you are in your 50s or beyond, a different procedure may make more sense. Lens replacement surgery swaps the natural lens for an artificial one, and multifocal or trifocal lenses can be chosen to help with near, intermediate and distance vision. It is also a route for people whose corneas are not suited to laser.
Weighing up the risks
Every procedure carries risks, and a good consultation will cover them in full. With laser, the possible effects include temporary dryness, glare or halos, and occasionally a follow-up treatment to fine-tune the result.
An ICL involves surgery inside the eye, so the risks are different. Cataracts are an important long-term consideration, and the Royal College of Ophthalmologists notes that they may develop earlier in life after any type of implant of this kind. Other risks include infection, a rise in eye pressure and, occasionally, a lens that needs to be replaced because of its size or position. Serious vision loss is very uncommon, but it is the kind of detail your surgeon will go through with you before you decide.
Getting a recommendation that fits your eyes
Choosing between the two should never be a guess. At Centre for Sight, which has been treating patients since 1996 and was the UK’s first provider of LASIK, you see the same consultant from your first consultation through to your aftercare. They will assess your corneas, your prescription and your overall eye health, and explain which options are safe and sensible for you, including why they might not recommend one.
If you are weighing up ICL vs laser eye surgery and want a clear answer for your own eyes, book a consultation and our team will talk you through the options.



